--> Skip to Main Content

Systematic Review

A guide on how to conduct systematic reviews in the health sciences.

Key steps involved in critical appraisal

Step 1: Note the type of study design in included studies based on a review question.

Step 2: Identify a valid quality assessment tool appropriate for a review.

Step 3: Two or more reviewers test the tool with a sample of included studies.

Step 4: Reviewers carry out critical appraisal of included studies independently and in duplicate.

Step 5: Tabulate and summarize results of critical appraisal.

Critical Appraisal Checklists

These checklists can be downloaded and used to access the applicability, reliability and validity of published research.

Critical Appraisal Checklist (Downloadable)